Misha my love. . . .
Jun 11th, 2007 by Paul Moor
{I’ve exhumed this from fifteen years ago, written in San Francisco three years before I returned to Berlin, revived here especially for Christine von Grafenstein, who wrote so kindly about my experience a week ago when two homicidal crows divebombed Maxe the Dauntless Dachshund and me.}
November 6, 1992
Misha My Love
From the very beginning, my little fawn-colored, nubbin-tailed French bulldog Misha had an almost preternatural ability to divine any intentions I might possibly have about going out. He detected the slightest deviation from my customary workaday routine, and switched on his considerable charm to persuade me I really did need him, indispensably, to go along. The destination didn’t interest him, just as long as he could come along and stay with me.
My taking the keys out of the inside lock on the front door would then galvanize him, but he waited - huge brown eyes spotlighting me, bat-ears erect, little black goblin face optimistic and eager - frozen in alert position for my decision. A dog-biscuit treat from me (thank you, Prof. Pavlov) meant he had to resign himself to stay behind, but if I did reach for his collar and leash he erupted, almost violently, his joy utterly unconfined. Usually he punctuated the few seconds before I finally opened the door with an impatient little dance step or two, bouncing up and down on his stubby little forelegs.
On October 29th, Misha turned twelve. My first French bulldog, Charlie, had died in Berlin at eleven. His successor Orje, who accompanied me when I moved to San Francisco, made it to twelve, when a stroke cruelly disabled and almost killed him. The day before Misha’s twelfth birthday last Thursday, I noticed his unusual panting when we came home from his third, early evening walk. On his birthday itself (in celebration of which I laced his dry Science Diet Light with a quarter-pound of ground round), I paid careful attention, and thought I noticed a new rapidity and shallowness in his breathing. During the election news that evening - turning on the TV always also turned Misha into a lapdog - he couldn’t seem to come to rest. As bedtime approached, his breathing sounded asthmatic. His temperature proved normal, though, so I decided against the impersonality of the Emergency Animal Hospital, but when Misha’s regular vet arrived to open his office at eight last Friday morning, he found us waiting for him.
Dr. Harris took blood and made chest X-rays, then diagnosed pulmonary edema and gave me two kinds of pills; the results of the blood analysis would decide whether he’d add an antibiotic. He wanted to see him again in a week - yesterday - for more X-rays. Misha responded encouragingly to the medicine, but he continued to pant, and during his four daily walks he took to scrutinizing and sniffing even the most minuscule diverting object down on his level, so that his walks turned into a plod, and finally into a trudge. He sometimes wheezed, and sometimes coughed. Sometimes an indefinable vocal sound accompanied every rapid, shallow breath. It developed very rapidly.
Yesterday, the morning of the second X-rays, Dr. Harris said his radiologist would come in late in the afternoon and he’d phone me that evening. Around 7:30 came the definitive diagnosis: “multiple malignant masses - everywhere” in the lungs. It had grown and spread - and would continue to grow and spread just as fast as it already had. Cancer restricted to lung tissue causes no pain, but I heard from Jim Harris that Misha’s cancer would go on confiscating his lungs’ still available breathing space - more, and more, and more. . . .
I’d learned something fundamentally important about love - not Eros, in Grecian terms, but Agape, non-erotic love - from an incident involving Orje, Misha’s Berlin predecessor. Everyone knows the old cliche about loving someone so much you’d be willing to die for them. Walking Orje one day, I saw an unleashed German shepherd the size of a locomotive charging towards us with the speed of an express train, unmistakable murder in his eye. Without even a split second to think, I instantaneously dropped to the ground and completely covered Orje with my own body. The attacker, thank God, found only Orje interesting as victim: he barked furiously, canicidally, but ignored me personally. A chance observer pointed out just what might well have happened to me under slightly different circumstances. My spontaneous protection of Orje made it clear I hadn’t really cared.
And I loved Misha even more than I’d loved Orje.
Perhaps only the old and lonely comprehend the unique status of a really beloved pet. When Charlie sickened and died in Berlin during the scope of a single hour, his death meant in fact the extermination of my entire family, and at one single stroke. The death of Orje, in San Francisco, repeated that same ordeal.
Dog shows, prizes, and the like have never seriously interested me, but I always welcomed any opportunity to brag about Misha, and he did have plenty to brag about. The owners of the Clovis, California kennel where he’d entered this vale of tears spotted him immediately as “an exceptionally elegant pup”, and kept him to raise as a show dog. His rejecting dam, unimpressed, refused to nurse Misha and his only surviving sibling, so he bonded abnormally early with humans. The rejected orphan Misha and the house cat adopted each other, and from then on he never encountered a cat he didn’t try - with the utmost tact and diplomacy - to buddy up with and cuddle up to. At the age of five, soon after Orje’s death, Misha came to bless my life. As long as he lived, he had an almost panic anxiety he’d find himself abandoned again.
His owners’ prescience had proved justified: Misha became an American Kennel Club champion before his first birthday, and at two he won the official A.K.C. rating as the second-finest French bulldog in the whole USA. I prized him not for that but for his inexhaustible, never-failing, frequently comical - even hilarious - sweetness; that little tough-guy mug of his camouflaged a heart of solid marshmallow. I’ve never seen any animal match Misha when it came to attracting spontaneous affection from strangers; during one single walk one record day, four different people stopped us and wound up down on the ground, cooing, fondling his ears. He accepted such obeisance graciously, as a matter of course, with a meaningful glance upward in my direction to make sure I saw it and took it in, but he never did become really blase about it.
Before taking him to the vet this afternoon, I emptied his water pan and feed dish and put them out of sight, along with his prized Nylon bones, to avoid them as reminders when I would come home alone; I also dropped his two new medicines into the trash.
When Dr. Harris applied the tourniquet to Misha’s right foreleg, to make the blood vessels bulge more accomodatingly, he said that in only twenty-four hours his peripheral circulation and blood pressure had deteriorated noticeably, and he might have to resort to a catheter - but then he did find a blood vesseladequate for the hypodermic syringe’s merciful needle. He assured me I’d done the humane thing by not waiting any longer.
Around 1985, when Orje had received his own lethal injection, his body had reacted by inflating his little lungs to the bursting point - what medical people call “the agonal gasp” - and then expelling that air in an unearthly, outraged howl I can still hear, and probably always will. Misha, thank God, gave up his own little ghost with the same quiet gentleness that characterized everything about him. With him standing on the examination table, me holding him in both my arms, my face buried in the fur on the back of his neck, his husky, muscular little body suddenly relaxed, then his legs gave way, and then we laid him - gently, gently - on his side, and I closed those enormous, glistening, dark brown eyes for him. Oh, my little love.
. . . And so, after a few minutes of unhurried leave-taking, I left with Jim Harris the thirty pounds or so of physical residuum my beloved, departed Misha had discarded and left behind him this afternoon, and came back to an apartment now of abysmal, aching emptiness. When I replaced the keys in the inside lock of the front door, that cyclic act forced me to think back only an hour or so to how Misha had reacted when I’d removed them. He’d looked as eager and optimistic as ever, uninterested in our destination as long as he could come along and stay with me, and when I’d reached for his collar and leash he’d reacted, as always, with that familiar little dance of his, bouncing up and down on those stubby little forelegs.









As I know I’ve told before, it was reading this piece that first blew me away with your writing skill. It wasn’t just that you wrote so well but it was also your subject matter that touched my heart in this piece, and at least in part it was the inspiration for my writing this at a similar moment in my life.
Since “Misha my love” first caught my eye when you posted it on the ILink Writers conference, you’ve brought me to tears many times. And then you’ve turned around and caused me to fall over in laughter at other times. Through both the tears and the laughter you’ve entertained me and educated me. I wonder how many other people down through the years would have loved the opportunity to speak such words directly to their favorite author. Thank you for sharing yourself with me.
I’ve always been a dog person whether they were in their puppy years or in their old dog years, and I think I always will be.
Our Cavalier King Charles Spaniel is only 4 years old, but I cannot prevent my imagination’s persistent urge to visit his aging and demise. I hope for Toby the same fate as I wish for myself–going to sleep and not waking up. The ordeal of euthanizing Toby would be onerous beyond my endurance.
Jerry, I once read that one reason dog-owners so sincerely mourn the death of a pet has to do with the maximum life-span a dog can expect - making that comparable to the death of a child . . . and you know how much mourning that causes.
Perry Nelson recommended your blog to me, and as I scanned it for the first time, this post caught my attention. I read it, and it brought me to tears. As one dog lover to another, I’m so sorry for your loss - even though it was so many years ago. I imagine that it still feels like yesterday.
I am a single woman with two dogs (Molly and Cruella) and those dogs mean everything to me. I’ve gone through so much with them this year - one being diagnosed with Cushing’s Disease, and the other being diagnosed with a three different types of cancer. Molly is being treated for Cushing’s and seems to be doing pretty well. Cruella went through some serious problems related to the cancer (she developed peritonitis shortly after removal of a malignant tumor attached to her colon) and almost didn’t pull through just a few months ago. She was transferred to the University of Tennessee, and when they told me that she may not pull through the peritonitis, I broke down like I’ve never broken down for a human being. I am happy to say that she did pull through the peritonitis, and she then transferred to Oncology. She iscancer-free at the moment, and I pray that it stays that way. It has been a long, difficult road, and I will be paying back the thousands of dollars in vet bills for a long time to come. But you know what? It’s a small price to pay.
I love those dogs, and there is nothing I wouldn’t do to ensure their health and happiness.
Best of luck to you. Thanks for sharing your story. Misha was a beautiful dog and will never be forgotten.
Thank you so much for reviving your memories especially for me and sharing them with us. Though heartrending they may be for the reader, I know that they are just memories for you. As time goes by …
But there are the funny parts and the good old twinkle in the eye too. I just loved it.
Naturally other people’s memories trigger off one’s own.
There was Molly, the barrelshaped mongrel (mostly Jack-Russel-Terrier) who decided one day to live with us instead of who, we never found out. In the end she was too sick to move house. On the way back from the vet I nearly caused an accident …
There was Bonamy the Rhodesian Ridgeback, born and raised in South Africa, forever frightened by thunderstorms, who loved chasing the Postman’s car until he was run down by it. I found him completely unblemished lying by the roadside.
There was Balu, the Hamburg born Rhodesian Ridgeback, who died with his head in my arms after a long discussion with the vet about the pros and cons of major surgery. In the end ratio succeded. One is allowed to treat pets more humane than human beeings. But that is neither here nor there.
And there was our 12 year old. But as time goes by….
As a reply to Paul’s comment I have to add, that there is a fundamental difference. One knows about the approximate life span of a pet, but one expects that children outlive their parents. But life is fragile and has to be lived from day to day.
And where please are the funny memories? They are there as well, and that’s why we can live with our memories.
Mr. Moor, I linked to this post from Trish’s website and what I read was truely beautiful. My heart goes out to you and to Misha. My mother once told me that there are several native american tribes that believe that when you die and pass into the next realm you stand at a bridge guarded by the animals with whom you have had contact in your life. If you were an unkind and unrespectful person, you would be turned back. If you were a kind respectful person you would be allowed passage across the bridge. I don’t know if what they believed is true, but I would like to think that when we do cross over into whatever is next that our four legged partners, because thats what they are, will be waiting to grant us passage. Best of luck.
Thanks so much for this nice note, Ryan - and best wishes and belated thanks also to Trish. Depending upon your age, you may or may not recall Will Rogers - at one time one of the most famous people in the USA. What you write about that native American belief about animals reminds me of a favorite Will Rogers observation of mine: “If there are no dogs in Heaven, then when I die I want to go where they went.” You’ll far more likely remember Snoopy, the dauntless Beagle in the immortal “Peanuts” comic strip. When its creator Charles Schulz died - and the strip, by his own request, died along with him - I saw a newspaper cartoon (I don’t recall by whom) showing Schulz and Snoopy arriving at the Pearly Gates to encounter a “No dogs allowed” sign - but also a St. Peter who said in effect: “For you, Mr. Schulz, I think we can make an exception….”